Educators don’t drive student failures; political neglect does
Jeff Yass, the wealthiest person in Pennsylvania and Gov. Greg Abbott’s $6 million man, has a passion for private school vouchers. That reportedly is the main reason he has spent millions of dollars in political contributions to candidates and officeholders, both in his home state and beyond, including the seven-figure donation that Abbott’s camp is calling the largest in Texas history.
He obviously expects Abbott to use the $6 million to boost the governor’s campaign to unseat pro-public education House members who voted against vouchers last year.
The co-founder of an investment firm whose personal wealth has been reported as $29 billion, Yass says he wants taxpayers to help send kids to private schools because public schools are “failing.” We have heard that line before from numerous voucher advocates, including the governor. It deliberately and unfairly deflects blame to educators. The people who work hard in public schools every school day and often after school aren’t neglecting their jobs or “failing” their students.
The Texas public education system is not failing. But schools have problems, and the ultimate blame for those belongs to, among others, the man on whom Yass just wasted – I hope – $6 million. The blame belongs to Abbott, his legislative allies and the like-minded policymakers who preceded them. Because of their neglect and misplaced priorities, Texas public schools are woefully under-funded, and untold thousands of school children are not ready to learn when they get to class – if they get there — because they are under-nourished, homeless or sick. More than 60 percent of our public school students are from low-income families, and the state leadership refuses to provide the quantity and quality of public support services these kids need.
Texas spends more than $4,000 less per-student than the national average, and average teacher pay is more than $7,700 less than the national average. Last year, Abbott and the Legislature had a record $33 billion budget surplus, presenting a great opportunity to play some catch-up. But when he didn’t get vouchers, Abbott peevishly refused to spend more on public schools. Now, more school districts are struggling with their budgets, which means it has become even more difficult for them to provide enough certified teachers and resources for students. Educators haven’t failed in their jobs. The governor has.
For years, Texas has also had the disgraceful distinction of being the national leader among the states in the percentage of residents without health insurance. Many of those people are children, many of school age, more of whom could be served by Medicaid or the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). But Texas is one of only 10 states that have not expanded Medicaid eligibility for poor people, even though the federal government under the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, would pay for most of the costs.
Texas also has some of the strictest income requirements for public health care in the country and makes it difficult – through red tape and excessive paperwork requirements — for people who are eligible for Medicaid to enroll in the program and stay enrolled. Last year alone, Texas dropped about one million children from Medicaid after the federal government removed Medicaid coverage protections imposed during the COVID pandemic.
Texas also has the second-highest rate of food insecurity in the country, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and again children are doing a lot of the suffering. The free meals at school help, but they aren’t enough. The USDA now has a summer program offering monthly stipends for food assistance for children when schools are closed, but Texas has refused to participate.
And Texas’ care system for foster children, a long-running federal lawsuit has revealed, has endangered the health, safety and lives of thousands of vulnerable kids over the years and still needs improving.
Diverting billions of tax dollars to unregulated private schools would worsen the plight of public schools and further weaken these important public assistance programs.
If Abbott’s billionaire benefactor from Pennsylvania really wants to make a positive difference for education in Texas, he will pick a school district with serious budgetary problems – there are many — and issue it a $6 million check to use as its leaders see fit.
The district could use that check to give $3,000 bonuses to 2,000 teachers. Or it could buy supplies for 7,092 classrooms. This is based on the average $846 annual out-of-pocket expense for supplies most recently reported by TSTA members.
If the district used the $6 million to purchase summer meals for students at the $40 monthly stipend set by USDA, it could feed 150,000 children.
Contributing $6 million – or any amount — to Greg Abbott is a waste for the school kids of Texas.
0 Comments