TSTA comments on new rules for educating English Language Learners
The comments were on proposed revisions to the education commissioner’s rules concerning the state plan for teaching ELL students.
We supported a letter submitted by the Texas Legislative Education Equity Coalition expressing concern that there should be clarification that alternative language programs maintain a content-focused orientation. Research indicates that this method of instruction is more culturally competent, a better method of English acquisition and overall better for English learners.
TSTA also suggested that the required professional development training be aligned with the suggested clarification of the alternative language program definition, include cultural competency training and be content-focused. We believe that this is better for students and would better position teachers to earn ESL/bilingual certification.
Read TSTA’s comments that were submitted to the commissioner on proposed revisions to the rules concerning the state plan for educating English Learners.
CTE programs: failing to meet the challenge of vocational education?
Nearly a year after Congress reauthorized the Carl D. Perkins Vocational and Technical Education Act, states are in the thick of developing the career technical education (CTE) plans the law requires, and by most accounts, the future looks bright. Indeed, high school CTE programs appear to have turned the corner on “vocational education’s” stubborn stigma from previous decades. So, can we conclude America’s current CTE offerings have solved the stubborn challenges of vocational education? Maybe not.
The demerits of merit pay
Do you know the difference between merit pay and incentive pay? Too often those terms are used interchangeably even though they refer to different salary systems. Incentive pay represents salary enhancements that incite teachers to do something like accepting teaching positions in high-poverty schools or achieving National Board Certification. Merit pay, on the other hand, is a salary reward based on usually arbitrary benchmarks such as student performance on state assessment instruments or even the teacher evaluation system.
Texas Administrative Code, Chapter 89, Subchapter BB was revised to align with Texas Education Code 29, Subchapter B, and to comply with new requirements under the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) and was adopted on July 15, 2018. As a result, requirements for PK-12 teachers serving English learners through English as a Second Language (ESL) program models were strengthened.
To clear up some common misconceptions in the field, some clarifications/talking points regarding these changes are provided below:
- The revised ESL certification requirements only apply to those teachers who are serving English learners through one of the state-approved ESL program models, not to all teachers.
- LEAs have the option of electing to provide ESL services through either ESL pull-out (requiring ELAR instruction delivered by a teacher certified for that grade level in ELAR and ESL) or through ESL content-based (requiring English learners to receive all content instruction by teachers certified at that grade level/content area and in ESL). Each is allowable under statute.
- LEAs may choose to implement a content-based ESL program model, which does require all content teachers of English learners to be ESL-certified, but this is just one of the two allowable options. Therefore, the blanket statement that the TEA is requiring all content teachers serving English learners to be ESL certified is not accurate.
- If an LEA chooses to implement an ESL pull-out program model, there are multiple ways to do so, including options to coordinate services between an ESL-certified teacher and the ELAR teacher of English learners; therefore, the blanket statement that all ELAR teachers need to obtain ESL certification is not accurate.
- Although sheltered instruction is no longer sufficient in fulfilling statutory requirements for serving English learners through ESL at the high school level, it continues to serve as a valuable component of effective ESL programming, not just at high school, but at all grade levels.
- The English Learner Support Division has provided guidance documents to support districts in calculating potential staffing needs and associated certification requirements, which can be found here: http://elltx.org/assessment.html.
Regarding the waiving of ESL certification testing fees, the TEA does not have the authority to do so. However, the English Learner Support Division is working with TEA legal and fiscal monitoring staff to provide detailed guidance for the allowable use of bilingual education allotment funds for this and related purposes. This guidance shall be posted to the TEA Bilingual/ESL web page and will be accessible at the link below:
Division of English Learner Support: EnglishLearnerSupport@tea.texas.gov
Student turnover slows academic growth
Meticulous reports flow in on enrollment, attendance, test scores, dropout rates and college-entrance exam results. You can track students by race and income at every school and pull up each teacher’s salary and experience. But no one is widely tracking a key group of students whose actions, experts say, may be thwarting efforts to improve education: Kids who move around a lot.
Texas is alone in its definition of mobility: Students in a school for less than 83 percent of the school year. That’s closer to the definition of chronic absenteeism, a related but different issue. Texas officials say that’s purposeful: They want to capture students who are moving as well as those who are chronically missing.
How dress codes criminalize males and sexualize females of color
When students are disciplined because of how they are dressed, they lose class time — for a five-minute hallway lecture, 20 minutes to search through a bin of “appropriate” clothes to wear, an hour-long trip home, or even a full-day suspension. Perhaps even worse than losing out on instructional time, they also receive the message — whether explicit or implicit — that there is something wrong with their clothing choices or their bodies.
Teaching civility and public discourse in the classroom
There’s been a lot of talk lately about what constitutes civility. Much of this debate illustrates why it’s so important to discuss this concept in the classroom—and why it’s critical we frame the conversation about civility with historical context. When we build these connections for students, it’s easier for them to understand current political discourse and to decide how to engage each other.
A Year ago the Supreme Court raised the bar for Special Ed. What’s happened since?
A year after the US Supreme Court ruled that schools must offer students with disabilities an education reasonably calculated to enable them to “make progress appropriate in light of the child’s circumstances,” what has changed? On the one hand, not much, if evaluating the dozens of special education cases that have cited Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District, which was decided March 22, 2017. Around 90 percent of those kinds of disputes between school districts and parents were decided in favor of districts; the notable exception was that of Endrew F. himself, the teenager with autism who was at the center of the Supreme Court case.
NEPC offers monthly education podcast
The National Education Policy Center, housed at the University of Colorado Boulder School of Education, is a resource for peer-reviewed education policy information. Each month from September through May the organization releases an NEPC Education Interview of the Month. This month, the interview discusses teacher accountability with Marilyn Cochran-Smith, Cawthorne Professor of Teacher Education for Urban Schools and director of the Doctoral Program in Curriculum and Instruction at the Lynch School of Education, Boston College.
More K-12 schools are providing additional services for homeless students
In the 2015-16 school year, the number of homeless students in Texas had increased by 3.5% to 115,676 and there were more than 1.3 million homeless students enrolled in public schools across the nation, according to the National Center for Homeless Education, and that is just the number of students who were identified as homeless. Homeless students are notoriously hard to identify because families or unaccompanied teens are often fearful or ashamed to make their status known. Teachers may be the first to notice signs of homelessness: fatigue, wearing the same clothes, carrying their belongings with them, or hoarding food.
The National Center for Homeless Education
Push for higher teacher pay has a new starting point: Facebook
The successful West Virginia teacher strike has lit the match for a spate of teacher uprisings across the country. The main place teachers are gathering to strategize? Facebook.
Trauma and learning in America’s classrooms
Whether working in a rural, urban or suburban district, all teachers should expect to confront issues with children who have experienced trauma — more than half of the students enrolled in public schools have faced traumatic or adverse experiences and one in six struggles with complex trauma (Felitti & Anda, 2009) — and all teachers should understand how trauma affects students’ social, emotional, and academic growth.
Research-tested benefits of brain breaks
Regular breaks throughout the school day—from short brain breaks in the classroom to the longer break of recess—are not simply downtime for students. Such breaks increase their productivity and provide them with opportunities to develop creativity and social skills.
States Confront New Mandate on School-Spending Transparency
A tricky financial-transparency requirement in the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) has cranked up tensions among state politicians, school district administrators, and civil rights activists over public understanding of how districts divvy up their money among schools. ESSA requires districts to break out school-level spending by December 2019—a first-time federal requirement. It’s a level of detail unknown even to most district superintendents. Read more
Schools missing in Trump infrastructure plan
President Donald Trump unveiled his $1.5 trillion infrastructure plan Monday. And, probably unsurprisingly, there are no explicit resources for refurbishing, renovating or constructing schools. Read more
When students assault teachers
In the 2015-16 school year, 5.8 percent of the nation’s 3.8 million teachers were physically attacked by a student. Almost 10 percent were threatened with injury, according to federal education data. Teacher victimization has been an understudied and under-publicized area. Read more
Charter schools prolonging segregation
A recent Associated Press analysis of national school enrollment data found that “as of school year 2014-2015, more than 1,000 of the nation’s 6,747 charter schools had minority enrollment of at least 99 percent, and the number has been rising steadily.”
ESSA requirements will reveal spending disparities within districts
ESSA requires states to report per-pupil expenditures for every local education agency and school in the state on annual report cards. But in the vast majority of districts, spending is accounted for at the district level. Average teacher salaries, average per-pupil expenditures — they’re all calculated districtwide.
Parents stressed by rigor of Kindergarten
Kindergarten, where children were once encouraged to play and adjust to the rhythms of the school day, has long been evolving. But many parents new to modern-day elementary schooling say they have been shocked to find their children in a pressure cooker of rigorous academics, standardized tests, homework and what seem like outrageous expectations.
How do we stop the exodus of minority teachers?
Minority teachers are being driven out of schools by poor working conditions at rates higher than their non-minority colleagues, which only undermines years of recruitment efforts that have targeted minority teachers.
The NEA Foundation courses are intended to develop collaborative skills and content knowledge. The courses promote union-district collaboration as a tool for systems change and were developed by field experts, using a rich selection of resources. Use the course content in whatever way best meets your needs – a whole course, a single session, or just an activity. New courses are in development and will be posted periodically.
To start today, simply register and login! http://www.neafoundation.org/pages/courses
Global Learning: Tools and Approaches
Curious how you can bring global competence to the classroom? This new course, designed for self-study or small groups, introduces participants to key ideas and methods for connecting their classrooms with the wider world. http://www.neafoundation.org/pages/courses
We Connect Now
We Connect Now is a website created in 2008 to connect and serve college students with disabilities. It has been linked to by colleges and universities and groups serving people with disabilities in all 50 states and 10 foreign countries and has been visited by people from 172 different countries. http://weconnectnow.wordpress.com (Also on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/pages/We-Connect-Now-National/136925609714725.)
Section 504 guide
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act requires that school districts provide a free appropriate public education to qualified students in their jurisdictions who have a major physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, regardless of the nature or severity of the disability. The U. S. Department offers a Disability Rights Reinforcement Guide, a compilation of guidance and data on key issues such as free appropriate public education, discipline, post-secondary, and technology.
Learn more about Section 504: http://nichcy.org/laws/section504#info
Download the guide: http://www2.ed.gov/documents/news/section-504.pdf
Resources on the Holocaust and Genocide
The Texas Holocaust and Genocide Commission assists elementary/secondary schools and universities with Holocaust and genocide programs. Classroom resources include lesson plans, posters, and oral histories. They also offer a video contest — the deadline is in March — and grants of up to $1000 for civic/citizenship or social responsibility projects. http://thgc.texas.gov
Bully Free: It Starts with Me
“Bully Free: It Starts with Me” is a groundbreaking NEA initiative to identify caring adults in schools and communities who will pledge to help bullied students. The adults will agree to listen carefully to the student and take action to stop the bullying. NEA will provide adults the resources they need to provide solace and support, ask the right questions and take the appropriate actions.
Apply for an NEA Foundation grant
The NEA Foundation has a video that provides a guided tour and detailed instruction of the online application for its popular Learning & Leadership Grants and Student Achievement Grants. The deadlines for these grants — which provide $2,000 for implementing proposals from individuals for Learning & Leadership Grants and $5,000 for team proposals for both — are Feb. 1, June 1, and Oct. 15. For more information, to apply online, or to watch the video, visit the NEA Foundation Grant website.
The NEA Academy website is devoted to supporting the professional development of teachers and education support professionals. The site features web-based lessons, classroom tips, and professional development courses, including the popular classroom management course “I Can Do It” as well as the NEA Teacher Toolkit and career information.
Are you a first-year teacher?
Get a great start on your new career with our links and resources for first year teachers!
Teachers in Transition
The Texas Workforce Commission and a statewide network of Workforce Solutions offices will assist all teachers in their efforts to find work. This site offers information to help you better navigate the workforce system including filing for unemployment insurance, registering to look for work, finding a new job and knowing where to go to get additional help if needed.